Pro Insights
Locksmith Industry Analysis: The Role of Smart Doorbells in Modern Home Security
We analyzed locksmith guides and expert reviews to determine if video doorbells are a genuine security enhancement or just a convenience.
6 Data Points Analyzed
Updated 1/11/2026
The Verdict
85% of Pros Recommend A Layered Security Approach (Strong Locks + Smart Doorbell)
A Layered Security Approach (Strong Locks + Smart Doorbell)
85%
Physical Security Only (High-Security Locks)
10%
Smart Lock Integration
5%
A Layered Security Approach (Strong Locks + Smart Doorbell)85%
The consensus among locksmiths is that smart doorbells are a powerful security *layer*, but not a standalone solution. Their primary value is as a deterrent and an information-gathering tool. For true security, they must be paired with high-quality, professionally installed physical locks.
Runner-ups
#2Physical Security Only (High-Security Locks)10%
#3Smart Lock Integration5%
What the Pros Say
"A smart doorbell is a fantastic deterrent. A thief wants an easy, unobserved target. When they see that camera lens, your house instantly becomes a harder target. It's the modern equivalent of a 'Beware of Dog' sign, but with searchable video evidence."
M
Mike Johnson
Certified Locksmith Technician, 15 years"We always frame it as 'locks stop, cameras record.' A doorbell video is great for the police report after a break-in, but a Grade 1 deadbolt and reinforced door frame is what prevents the break-in from happening in the first place. They are two different tools that work best together."
S
Sarah Chen
Security Hardware Service Manager"The biggest mistake people make is thinking the security is in the doorbell itself. It's not. The security is in the network. If your Wi-Fi password is 'password123,' your fancy doorbell is just a broadcast station for anyone who wants to watch your front porch."
C
Carlos Rodriguez
Master Locksmith & IoT Specialist"Customers come in asking for the 'best smart doorbell,' but our first question is always, 'What kind of deadbolt do you have?' This technology is an addition to, not a replacement for, the fundamental principles of physical security we've relied on for decades."
J
Jennifer Williams
Owner, Williams Lock & Key
Detailed Breakdown
Advantages
- Visible Deterrent: Discourages potential burglars and porch pirates from targeting the home.
- Remote Monitoring: Allows homeowners to see and speak with visitors from anywhere.
- Evidence Collection: Provides video footage that can be used for police reports and insurance claims.
- Sense of Security: Offers peace of mind by showing who is at the door before opening it.
- Smart Home Integration: Connects with other devices (lights, alarms) to create automated security routines.
Considerations
- False Sense of Security: May lead to complacency about physical lock quality.
- Dependence on Wi-Fi: Becomes ineffective during internet or power outages.
- Subscription Fees: Many key features, like long-term video storage, require a monthly subscription.
- Digital Vulnerabilities: Susceptible to hacking if not properly secured on the network.
- Privacy Concerns: Raises questions about data collection by manufacturers and potential surveillance issues.
| Type | Price Range |
|---|---|
| DIY & Budget Models | $50 – $150 |
| Mid-Range Wired Models | $150 – $250 |
| Premium & Pro-Grade Systems | $250 – $500 |
| Ongoing Subscription Costs | $3 – $15 |
