How to choose a reliable and trustworthy locksmith to avoid scams, poor quality work, security risks, and overpricing. Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)

    Don't get scammed. A 25-year vet's guide on how to spot a real locksmith and avoid the drill-and-bill clowns. Learn what to check and what to ask.

    DIY Fix: $5–$20
    Pro Help: $150–$500
    Time: 15–120 min

    Quick Answer

    First, look for a local company with a real, verifiable address (not just a P.O. box) and a local phone number – beware of 1-800 numbers that could connect you to a call center. Second, ask if they are licensed (if your state requires it) and insured right on the phone. Third, *always* get a firm quote in writing before they start any work. A standard lockout might range from $100 to $350, but scammers will inflate that significantly, especially with hidden fees. A legitimate professional can almost always pick a standard lock without drilling it. If they immediately suggest drilling, that's a huge red flag that you're about to be overcharged for unnecessary damage and a replacement lock.

    How to choose a reliable and trustworthy locksmith to avoid scams, poor quality work, security risks, and overpricing. Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide) visual diagram
    Visual guide for diagnosing key fob issues

    Common Symptoms

    You get a bad gut feeling about a locksmith's credibility or experience.
    You're worried about the security risk of giving someone access to your locks.
    You feel like you're about to be overcharged, or the pricing is vague.
    You're concerned the 'fix' might be a drill, causing more damage and cost.
    You can't tell if you're talking to a real local business or a scam call center.

    Possible Causes

    Lack of state or local regulation in the locksmith industry allows unqualified people to operate freely.
    Scammers use aggressive online advertising and fake local addresses to trick people in emergency situations.
    Homeowners are often in a panic when locked out and rush to hire the first person they can find.
    Most folks don't know what to look for in a professional a pro, like asking for a license or a physical address.
    The 'drill-and-bill' method is a common scam where technicians unnecessarily destroy a lock to charge for a replacement.

    Step-by-Step Diagnosis

    1

    Step 1

    On the phone, ask for the legal business name and a physical, searchable street address. A P.O. box is a red flag.

    2

    Step 2

    Ask if they are licensed (if required in your state) and insured. Tell them you'll want to see proof.

    3

    Step 3

    Get a total estimated cost *before* you agree to have them come out. Reject vague '$19 service fee' offers.

    4

    Step 4

    When they arrive, check that their vehicle is marked and their ID matches the company name. If not, send them away.

    5

    Step 5

    Question any immediate attempt to drill the lock. Ask them to try picking it first. A real pro will almost always try non-destructive entry first.

    How to choose a reliable and trustworthy locksmith to avoid scams, poor quality work, security risks, and overpricing. Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)
    Key fob troubleshooting and repair overview

    DIY vs Professional Costs

    Vetting a Locksmith
    DIY$0
    Pro$0
    Time15 minutes
    Emergency Home/Car Lockout
    DIYN/A
    Pro$100 - $350
    Time30-60 mins
    Rekeying One Lock Cylinder
    DIYN/A
    Pro$40 - $100
    Time1 hour
    Installing a New Deadbolt
    DIY$25-$150
    Pro$150 - $400
    Time1-2 hours

    When to Call a Professional Locksmith

    • You're locked out of your car or house. Don't break a window; it's more expensive.
    • You've moved into a new property or an employee with keys has left your business. You need to rekey the locks immediately.
    • A lock is sticking, broken, or feels 'gritty'. Get it serviced before it fails and locks you out (or in).
    • You want to upgrade your security with better deadbolts, keypad locks, or a master key system.
    • You've lost your keys and are worried about who might find them. Time to rekey.

    Prevention Tips

    • Find a reputable local locksmith *before* you have an emergency and save their number in your phone.
    • Give a spare key to a trusted neighbor or nearby family member to avoid lockouts.
    • Inspect your locks annually. If one feels sticky or grinds, get it serviced before it fails completely.
    • Always get a firm quote in writing (or text/email) before any work begins to prevent surprise charges.
    • If a technician shows up in an unmarked van or gets pushy about drilling, trust your gut and send them away.
    How to choose a reliable and trustworthy locksmith to avoid scams, poor quality work, security risks, and overpricing. Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide) professional repair detail
    Professional key fob repair and programming

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Related Guides

    Need Professional Help?

    Find top-rated locksmith experts in your area

    Find Local Pros