How much does it cost to repair a tile roof?

For a simple, single-tile repair, you're usually looking at a service call fee of $200-$500. If the job is bigger, involving multiple tiles or underlayment work, the cost can go from $700 to over $3,000, depending on the complexity and materials.

What causes roof tiles to break or crack?

The most common culprits are direct impacts from hail or falling tree branches, and improper foot traffic from other contractors. Age and extreme weather, like freeze-thaw cycles, can also make tiles brittle and prone to cracking over time.

Can I replace a single broken roof tile myself?

If it's on a low-slope, single-story roof and you're comfortable with heights and basic tools, maybe. But you risk breaking surrounding tiles. If the roof is steep, high, or you have S-shaped tiles, it's best to call a pro. Messing it up will cost more in the long run.

What are the signs of a leaking tile roof?

The most obvious sign is a brown water stain on your ceiling or walls. You might also notice a musty smell in your attic or see dark streaks on the wood decking from inside the attic. Don't wait until you see a drip; the stain is your call to action.

How long do tile roofs typically last?

The concrete or clay tiles themselves can last 50 years or more. However, the underlayment beneath them is the real weak link. An old felt underlayment might only last 20-25 years, while modern synthetic ones can last 30-40. Your roof's real lifespan is tied to its underlayment.

Does ignoring a broken tile lead to bigger issues?

Yes, absolutely. A single broken tile is an open door for water to get to your underlayment and roof deck. A slow, unnoticed leak can cause thousands of dollars in wood rot, insulation damage, and mold remediation down the road. It's the definition of 'a stitch in time saves nine.'

Tile Roof Repair (Cracked & Broken Tiles) (Troubleshooting & Fixes)

Quick Answer

Okay, so you've found a cracked or broken tile on your roof. This isn't just a cosmetic issue; the tile's primary job is to shed water quickly, protecting the crucial waterproof underlayment beneath. When a tile is damaged, water can penetrate directly to this underlayment. Over time, exposure to moisture and UV rays degrades the underlayment, eventually leading to leaks into your home. The immediate fix is to replace the broken tile, but it's essential to inspect the underlayment underneath for any damage. For a simple replacement of one or two tiles, you can expect a professional to charge roughly $250-$600, depending on the tile type and accessibility.

Tile Roof Repair (Cracked & Broken Tiles) (Troubleshooting & Fixes) visual diagram — Visual guide for diagnosing key fob issues

Common Symptoms

Cracked or broken roof tiles

Slipped or dislodged roof tiles

Visible leaks inside the home (ceiling stains, dripping water)

Water damage to the home's structure (wood rot)

Mold growth

Missing tiles

Possible Causes

Weather damage (wind, hail, extreme temperatures)

Physical impact (falling debris, foot traffic)

Wear and tear over time

Poor original installation

Underlayment deterioration (leading to leaks even with intact tiles)

Step-by-Step Diagnosis

Step 1

Visually inspect the roof for cracked, broken, or missing tiles from the ground using binoculars.

Step 2

If safe, access the roof to closely examine individual tiles for damage and check for slipped tiles. Use proper safety gear.

Step 3

Carefully lift the overlapping tile and remove the broken pieces to inspect the underlayment beneath for signs of deterioration or water penetration.

Step 4

Check the attic or interior ceilings for water stains or active leaks, tracing them back to their source on the roof if possible.

Step 5

Assess the overall condition of the roof for widespread damage versus localized issues.

Tile Roof Repair (Cracked & Broken Tiles) (Troubleshooting & Fixes) — Key fob troubleshooting and repair overview

DIY vs Professional Costs

Repair Type	DIY Cost	Professional Cost	Time Required
Single Tile Replacement (Simple)	$20 - $75	$250 - $600	1-2 hours
Multiple Tiles / Small Section	$50 - $200	$700 - $2,000	2-4 hours
Underlayment Spot Repair	$75 - $250 (materials)	$1,000 - $3,500+	4-8 hours (1 day)

Single Tile Replacement (Simple)

DIY$20 - $75

Pro$250 - $600

Time1-2 hours

Multiple Tiles / Small Section

DIY$50 - $200

Pro$700 - $2,000

Time2-4 hours

Underlayment Spot Repair

DIY$75 - $250 (materials)

Pro$1,000 - $3,500+

Time4-8 hours (1 day)

When to Call a Professional Roofing

When multiple tiles are damaged, or the damage covers a large area.
If you see any signs of leaks inside your home, like ceiling stains.
When you inspect the underlayment and it appears torn, brittle, or compromised.
If your roof is steep, on a second story, or you aren't comfortable with heights and safety procedures.
When dealing with complex or specialty tiles like slate or certain clay profiles that require special tools.
If you can't find an exact match for your existing tiles.

Prevention Tips

Conduct regular roof inspections from the ground with binoculars to catch minor issues early.
Keep trees trimmed well away from the roof to prevent branches from falling on it.
Avoid walking on tile roofs unless absolutely necessary, and if so, learn the proper technique to walk on the lower overlap of the tiles to prevent breakage.
Ensure proper original installation with high-quality materials, especially the underlayment.
Address small repairs promptly to prevent them from escalating into larger, more costly problems.

Tile Roof Repair (Cracked & Broken Tiles) (Troubleshooting & Fixes) professional repair detail — Professional key fob repair and programming

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Guides

Roof Leak Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)

Notice water stains? Our 2024 guide helps you troubleshoot and fix a roof leak. Learn common causes, DIY vs. pro costs, and when to call an expert.

Read guide

Clogged Gutters: Troubleshooting & Fixes from a 25-Year Pro

Tired of overflowing gutters wrecking your house? A 25-year vet shows you how to spot the signs, clear the gunk, and stop a small clog from becoming a huge repair bill.

Read guide