Quick Answer
Okay, so your water's gone lukewarm, right? The first thing to check is the thermostat setting on the tank—it's usually free to fix if it just got bumped down. If you've got an electric heater, it's a good bet one of your two heating elements is shot, often the lower one. It's a common problem. For a gas heater, it could be sediment buildup, a failing thermocouple, or even a blocked vent. You might be able to fix some issues for nothing, or for the cost of a $15-$50 part. If you're calling a professional, a simple fix is usually in the $150-$350 range, but more complex issues like a gas control valve can cost $400 or more.
Common Symptoms
Possible Causes
Step-by-Step Diagnosis
Step 1
Check the thermostat dial on the water heater to ensure it is set to 120-125°F.
Step 2
For an electric heater, check the circuit breaker panel for a tripped breaker. Reset it once.
Step 3
For a gas heater, visually inspect the pilot light to ensure it is lit (if applicable).
Step 4
If you have an electric heater and a multimeter, turn off the power and test the continuity of both the upper and lower heating elements.
Step 5
Listen for popping or rumbling sounds when a gas heater's burner is on, which indicates significant sediment buildup.
Step 6
If the water was recently worked on, a broken dip tube could be the issue, causing immediate mixing of cold and hot water.
DIY vs Professional Costs
| Repair Type | DIY Cost | Professional Cost | Time Required |
|---|---|---|---|
Flush Sediment from Tank | $0 - $20 | $150 - $350 | 1-2 hours |
Replace Electric Heating Element | $25 - $50 | $250 - $400 | 2-3 hours |
Replace Gas Thermocouple | $15 - $30 | $150 - $350 | 30 minutes |
Replace Gas Control Valve | N/A (Pro only) | $400 - $800+ | 1-2 hours |
When to Call a Professional Water Heater
- If you smell gas anytime, for any reason. Evacuate and call the gas company immediately.
- If you are not 100% comfortable and knowledgeable about working with 240-volt electricity.
- If an electric water heater's circuit breaker trips immediately after you reset it.
- If the diagnosis points to a bad gas control valve.
- If water is leaking from the main tank body itself, which means it needs to be replaced.
- If you've tried the simple DIY fixes and the problem persists.
Prevention Tips
- Flush the water heater tank annually to remove sediment, especially in hard water areas.
- Inspect the anode rod every 3-5 years and replace it if it's heavily corroded to prevent tank rust.
- Test the Temperature & Pressure (T&P) relief valve annually to make sure it hasn't seized.
- Keep the thermostat set to a safe and efficient 120-125°F to prevent scalding and save energy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Guides
Lack of hot water heater maintenance leading to decreased efficiency, premature failure, and reduced lifespan Troubleshooting & Fixes
Inefficient water heater operation due to insufficient insulation, leading to higher energy consumption and increased utility bills. Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)
Is your water heater bleeding heat and money? Our veteran tech's guide shows you how to troubleshoot and fix poor insulation for lower utility bills. Easy fixes inside.
Safely and effectively shutting down a water heater during an emergency or for maintenance to prevent further damage or hazards. Troubleshooting & Fixes
Water Heater TPR Valve Leaking: Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)
Your water heater's TPR valve leaking? A veteran tech explains why it's happening, how to fix it, and when to call a pro. Learn the real causes and costs.
Noisy Water Heater (Popping, rumbling, hissing, whining, banging sounds) Troubleshooting & Fixes
Going Tankless: DIY Dream or Professional Necessity? Troubleshooting & Fixes (2024 Guide)
Thinking of swapping to a tankless water heater? A veteran tech breaks down the real costs and dangers of DIY vs. hiring a pro. Don't touch that gas line yet.
Need Professional Help?
Find top-rated water heater experts in your area